Planning where to eat in the Hamptons this summer? Whether you’re craving lobster rolls in Montauk, or date-night pasta in East Hampton, this guide breaks down the top restaurants you need to try in the Hamptons this summer.

Montauk Restaurants

Duryea’s Lobster Deck – Best Waterfront Seafood in Montauk

Duryea’s Lobster Deck: A Montauk classic. Grab a lobster cobb salad, seafood tower, and a glass of rosé, then settle in for a sunset waterfront dinner that’s as much about the vibe as it is the food.

• Top Dishes:
  • Clam Bake (get the bread to dip in the sauce!)
  • Lobster Cobb Salad
  • Royal Seafood Tower 

Gigi’s at Gurneys

Gigi’s at Gurney’s (NEW!): Gigi’s is the newest addition to Gurney’s and brings elevated seaside dining with a focus on fresh local ingredients. Perfect for a date night or long lunch after the spa.

Ocean Club at Montauk Yacht Club

Ocean Club at Montauk Yacht Club: Chef Jarad McCarroll is doing elegant coastal fare – think steaks, seafood, and a view. Classy without being stiff.

• Top Dishes:
  • Wood-Fired Braai Lobster
  • Grilled Ribeye Steak
  • Raw Bar Selection

Mary Lou’s Montauk – Palm Beach Vibes & Cocktails

Mary Lou’s Montauk: Palm Beach meets Montauk. Come for cocktails and small bites, stay for the DJ and dreamy interiors.

• Top Dishes:
  • A5 Wagyu Burger
  • Altima Caviar Tower
  • Prime Cut Steak

Navy Beach

Navy Beach: Chill vibes, beachy cocktails, and one of the best sunset tables in town.

• Top Dishes:
  • Buttermilk Fried Chicken
  • Lobster Roll
  • Mac & Cheese

Gosman’s Topside Restaurant

Gosman’s: As a staple seafood destination in Montauk, Gosman’s Dock is renowned for its fresh seafood and refreshing drinks served in a laid-back coastal atmosphere.

• Top Dishes:
  • Lobster Roll
  • Stuffed Clams
  • Lobster Bisque

East Hampton Restaurants

Swifty’s at The Hedges Inn

Swifty’s at The Hedges Inn: A Hamptons take on the NYC staple. Cozy up in this charming inn and order the crab cakes.

• Top Dishes:
  • Crab Cakes
  • French Fries
  • Lobster Salad

Wayan & Ma·dé Out East at EHP Resort:

Wayan & Ma·dé Out East at EHP Resort: Chef Cédric Vongerichten brings Indonesian-French fusion to the waterfront, offering dishes like pork ribs with soy-tamarind glaze and whole black sea bass.

• Top Dishes:
  • Warm Balinese Lobster Roll
  • Charred Chicken Lombok
  • Caramelized Beef Tenderloin

Camp Rubirosa – NYC-Style Pizza Pop-Up in East Hampton

Camp Rubirosa: The team behind NYC’s Rubirosa introduces a summer pop-up featuring their signature pizzas and handmade pastas, bringing a slice of the city to the Hamptons.

• Top Dishes:
  • Tie-Dye Pizza
  • Vodka Sauce Pasta
  • Meatballs

Nick & Toni’s

Nick & Toni’s: Head to Nick & Toni’s in East Hampton for a delicious Italian dinner. This local spot has some wonderful dishes like steak, pizza, pasta, and their pre-fixe dinner for $29.

Top Dishes:

• Rigatoni alla Buttera
• Roasted Chicken
• Pizza with Seasonal Veg

Crazy Pizza

Crazy Pizza: Imported from Europe, this spot brings flair and flavor—expect DJs, fancy pies, and a yeast-free crust.

• Top Dishes:
  • San Danielle pizza
  • Tartufo pizza
  • Tiramisu served table-side

Amagansett

Bostwick’s Chowder House – Laid-Back Seafood Favorite in Amagansett

Bostwick’s: My favorite restaurant out east has to be Bostwick’s. It’s known for its casual, nautical atmosphere, and has some of the best seafood in the Hamptons. Be sure to order the fried fish tacos, buttered lobster roll, shrimp cocktail and the coconut shrimp spring rolls.

Top Dishes:

• Fried Fish Tacos
• Buttered Lobster Roll
• Coconut Shrimp Spring Rolls

The Lobster Roll Restaurant aka Lunch

The Lobster Roll: Known locally as “Lunch,” The Lobster Roll is famous for its classic lobster rolls served in a casual roadside setting that is a must-try!

Top Dishes:

• Classic Lobster Roll
• Clam Strips
• New England Clam Chowder

Bridgehampton

Jean-Georges at Topping Rose House

Jean-Georges at Topping Rose House: Set in a beautifully restored mansion, this restaurant offers a refined menu crafted by renowned chef Jean-Georges Vongerichten perfect for special occasions.

• Top Dishes:
  • Tuna Tartare with Avocado and Spicy Radish
  • Grand Plateau
  • Burrata with Rhubarb Compote

Artie’s in the Hamptons

Artie’s in the Hamptons: Artie’s is back for a second season in the Hamptons with an extensive menu and it’s a great spot for a laid-back meal.

• Top Dishes:
  • Spicy Rigatoni
  • Veal Parm
  • Peperoncini Martini

Almond

Almond: Creative and cozy with a local following. This is the spot that is always consistent and a perfect place to meet up with friends.

Top Dishes:

• Roast Chicken
• Art’s Pork Chop
• Mussels

Sag Harbor

Le Bilboquet – Chic French Dining on the Water in Sag Harbor

Le Bilboquet: French-inspired, waterfront, and always packed. Worth the hype.

• Top Dishes:
  • Les Moules Marinières et Frites
  • Heirloom Tomato Salad 
  • Seared Sea Scallops

Sag Harbor Tavern

Sag Harbor Tavern: If you are looking for a classic burger or incredible grilled branzino out east, look no further than Sag Harbor Tavern. They are open Friday-Saturday, kid-friendly, and the perfect spot for a casual dinner.

• Top Dishes:
  • Classic Burger
  • Fish and Chips
  • Brick Chicken with Mash + Gravy

Tutto il Giorno

Tutto il Giorno: Owned by Gabby Karan de Felice, this stylish Italian eatery serves fresh, seasonal dishes in a beautifully designed space embodying the essence of Hamptons dining.

• Top Dishes:
  • Cioppino
  • Rigatoni
  • Risotto

Southampton

F?NIKS

Feniks (NEW!): Chef Douglas Gulija’s new venture pays homage to his Croatian roots, presenting a fine dining experience with unique seafood creations and a chef’s counter offering an intimate culinary journey.

• Top Dishes:
  • Local Black Sea Bass with Udon Noodles
  • Catsmo Wild Salmon with Spring Pea Pancake
  • Eight-Course Chef’s Tasting Menu

Donohue’s Steakhouse

Donohue’s Steakhouse: A classic Upper East Side establishment expands to Southampton, bringing its renowned steaks, chops, and timeless ambiance to the East End.

• Top Dishes:
  • Prime Chopped Beef Burger
  • Yankee Pot Roast
  • Broiled Sea Scallops

Sant Ambroeus

Sant Ambroeus: Chic, reliable, and always delicious. Go for a cappuccino, stay for the pasta.

Top Dishes:

• Caprese Salad
• Spaghetti Pomodoro
• Principessa Cake

Calissa

Calissa: Calissa specializes in Mediterranean-inspired cuisine, including wood-fired dishes and an extensive wine list, all enjoyed in a picturesque outdoor garden.

Top Dishes:

• Grilled Halloumi
• Whole Branzino
• Truffle Lobster Pasta

Hampton Bays

Cowfish

Cowfish: Waterfront views, fresh seafood, sushi, and tropical cocktails. Perfect for a pre-Montauk dinner.

Top Dishes:

• Sushi Rolls
• Tuna Poke Nachos
• Lobster Mac & Cheese

 Final Tips for Dining in the Hamptons

• Make reservations early – places book up fast, especially on weekends.
• Try lunch – some of the best meals happen midday (and without the wait).
• Bookmark this post – I’ll keep it updated all summer with new spots, pop-ups, and returning favorites.

Frequently Asked Questions – Hamptons Dining

Need more planning help? Don’t miss my Hamptons weekend guide, Sag Harbor travel tips, and where to find the best coffee in the Hamptons.