Left Hand Coffee Montauk: Menu, Hours & What to Order
Quick answer: Left Hand Coffee is an espresso bar at 83 S Elmwood Avenue in downtown Montauk. The Nutella latte is the signature order, and the official menu also includes cold brew, espresso drinks, chai, matcha and several non-dairy milks. Hours change seasonally, so check the cafe-hours page before you go.
Left Hand Coffee Menu: What to Order
The Iced Nutella Latte is iconic—chocolatey, smooth and just the right amount of sweet. The current official Left Hand Coffee menu also lists cold brew, espresso, macchiato, cappuccino, cortado, latte, chai, matcha and seasonal flavors. Oat, coconut, almond and macadamia milk are listed as non-dairy options.
Go-to orders:
- Iced Nutella Latte
- Cold Brew with Oat Milk
- Banana Bread or a Breakfast Sandwich (when available)
Why It’s One of the Best Coffee Shops in Montauk
Left Hand Coffee in Montauk has that effortlessly cool vibe. It’s tucked off South Elmwood Ave, steps from the beach and walkable to everywhere downtown. There’s a laid-back, minimalist interior, and a small outdoor patio if you want to hang for a bit. It’s a grab-and-go spot that doesn’t feel rushed, and every time I’m in Montauk I start my day here. No exceptions.
Left Hand Coffee Hours & Location
- Address: 83 S Elmwood Ave, Montauk, NY 11954
- Hours: Seasonal. The official page was still displaying September hours when checked in October 2026, so confirm the current cafe hours or check Instagram before leaving.
- Instagram: @lefthandcoffee
Pro Tips
- Parking: There’s limited street parking nearby—come early or walk from your hotel/rental.
- Crowds: Gets busiest around 9–10 AM on weekends.
- Pair it with: A pastry from Montauk Bake Shoppe or a walk to the beach.
Left Hand Coffee FAQs
What should I order at Left Hand Coffee? The iced Nutella latte is the Shorehouse pick. For something less sweet, order cold brew or a classic espresso drink made with the shop’s own roasts.
Does Left Hand Coffee have non-dairy milk? Yes. The official menu lists oat, coconut, almond and macadamia milk.
What time does Left Hand Coffee open? Hours change with the season. Check the official cafe-hours page or @lefthandcoffee on the day you plan to visit.
Planning a Day in Montauk?
Left Hand Coffee is also featured in:
Shorehouse Newsletter
The monthly edit, in your inbox.
Travel, hotels, and what’s worth your attention. Once a month, never more.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
